Opening Hours:
Cat Pick
The Pet Market NYC's 30+ year family-owned operation on West 57th creates a level of product knowledge and customer relationship depth that chain retailers cannot match. The same-day delivery service in Manhattan solves the logistical challenge of carrying heavy cat supplies in a city without cars. For Midtown West, Columbus Circle, and Hell's Kitchen cat owners, this store provides both quality and convenience.
The Pet Market W57th earns strong reviews for the knowledgeable, helpful staff and the quality of its curated product selection. Multiple cat owners describe staff who genuinely know the products and make tailored recommendations based on individual cat needs. The same-day delivery service is praised as a significant convenience. Long-term clients describe genuine relationships with staff built over years of visits.